Philosophy

Ego Is the Enemy

Overview

Ryan Holiday defines ego as an unhealthy belief in your own importance. The book has three parts, Aspire, Success and Failure, and argues that ego does damage in each. It stops beginners from learning, makes the successful careless and turns setbacks into bitterness. Each short chapter pairs a piece of advice with a figure from history, such as General George Marshall or Howard Hughes. Holiday draws on Stoic writers.

In brief

Talk less

Holiday warns that talking about a plan can feel like progress and use up the energy needed for the work. He advises keeping quiet until there is something to show.

Stay a student

Holiday tells how the guitarist Kirk Hammett sought out a teacher after joining Metallica. He argues that thinking you already know enough is how skilled people stop improving.

Handling success

Success brings praise, money and a sense of entitlement, which Holiday says cloud judgement. He holds up leaders who stayed sober about their own role and kept to their standards.

Alive time and dead time

Holiday takes this from Robert Greene. Dead time is spent waiting passively, alive time is spent learning. He cites Malcolm X, who educated himself by reading in prison.

Who should read this

Ambitious people early in their careers, and anyone who has recently had a big success or a painful failure and is not sure how to carry it.

Who might skip it

Skip if you dislike the 'here is a Stoic idea, here are four famous people who exemplified it' format — Holiday uses it relentlessly, and critics have pointed out that the case studies are often cherry-picked. Skip also if you've read his other books; there's significant overlap.

What he means by ego

Holiday does not use ego in the technical sense psychologists do. He means an unhealthy belief in your own importance: arrogance, the need to be recognised, the sense that you are special and the rules are for others. He separates this from confidence, which is earned through work and can be tested against results.

The book is arranged in three parts that match the stages most people pass through repeatedly. You are aspiring to something, or you have achieved success, or you have failed. He argues ego damages each stage in a different way. It stops beginners from learning, blinds successful people to their faults, and makes failure harder to recover from.

He writes from experience. He rose very quickly in marketing while still in his early twenties, and then watched people he had admired and worked for bring themselves down. He admits his own ego caused him trouble in those years. Most of the book, though, consists of short stories from history, sport and business, each illustrating one habit.

Talk less and stay a student

Holiday's first warning to beginners is about talking. Describing the book you will write or the company you will build feels like progress. It uses up energy the work itself needs, and the praise you collect for the plan reduces your hunger to carry it out. He advises keeping quiet and letting the finished work speak.

The second habit is remaining a student. His example is Kirk Hammett, who had just become lead guitarist of the band Metallica, a position most young players would treat as proof they had arrived. Hammett decided he was not yet good enough and went to a teacher, Joe Satriani, for lessons.

Holiday also passes on a system from the fighter Frank Shamrock. You need someone better than you to learn from, someone at your level to test yourself against, and someone less experienced to teach. Teaching shows you what you do not fully understand. A junior accountant might study under a senior partner, compare notes with a colleague from the same batch, and help an intern with the basics.

Doing the work or being seen

A choice runs through the first part of the book: whether you want to be somebody or to do something. Holiday takes it from John Boyd, an American air force strategist who put this choice to officers he mentored. One road leads to promotions and titles, and may require you to compromise. The other leads to real work that matters, possibly with little recognition.

From this comes what Holiday calls the canvas strategy. When you are junior, make other people look good. Clear the path for those above you, hand them ideas, take the dull tasks nobody wants. He mentions the American football coach Bill Belichick, who started out analysing game film, a chore that senior coaches disliked.

This is hard on the pride of a new graduate who feels overqualified for the tasks he is given. Holiday's answer is that the person who makes himself useful learns how everything works and earns trust that pays off later.

He is also suspicious of passion. He prefers purpose and steady effort to excitement.

The dangers of success

Holiday thinks success is where ego does most harm, because results seem to confirm that you were right all along. People stop listening. They begin to believe their own story, in which every win came from their talent and nothing from timing or help.

His cautionary figure is Howard Hughes, who inherited a profitable business and had real ability, then wasted much of both through impulsive projects and a refusal to be questioned. Against him Holiday sets people who kept learning after they had won. He describes how Genghis Khan absorbed the skills and technology of each people he conquered instead of assuming his own ways were best.

The remedy offered is attention to standards over outcomes. The coach Bill Walsh took over a losing team and concentrated on how every small job was done, trusting that results would follow. Holiday also recommends staying sober about praise and remembering how small any career is against the scale of the world.

Handling failure

Everyone fails at some point, and Holiday argues that ego turns a setback into a disaster. The ego cannot accept being wrong, so it blames others or takes a bigger risk to win back what was lost. A person with less ego can look at what happened and begin repairs.

He borrows a distinction from the author Robert Greene between alive time and dead time. In any period of waiting or confinement, you either use the hours to learn or you let them pass. His example is Malcolm X, who spent his prison years reading and educating himself and came out a different man. Someone who has lost a job can treat the months of searching the same way, by gaining a skill while the applications are out.

He also suggests judging yourself by your own standard. If you did the work as well as it could be done, that has to be enough, because the reception is outside your control. Praise and criticism will both be unreliable guides.

Try this week

  1. Choose one goal you have been telling people about and spend that talking time on the work itself this week.
  2. Identify one person more skilled than you and ask them a specific question about their work.
  3. Take one boring task off your manager's or teacher's hands without being asked and without mentioning it afterwards.
  4. After your next success, write down two things outside your control that helped it happen.
  5. If you are in a waiting period, pick one skill to learn during it and set a daily time for practice.

Our honest take

The argument rests on stories about famous people chosen to fit the point, and history offers plenty of proud, self-promoting people who did very well. Holiday defines ego so loosely that almost any failure can be blamed on it afterwards, which makes the claim difficult to test. There is no research behind the advice, only anecdote and quotation. The chapters are short and similar, and by the third part the message has been repeated many times.

"The first principle is that you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool."

— Richard Feynman, quoted in the book

If you liked this

The Obstacle Is the Way is the first book in the set. For the original source, Marcus Aurelius's Meditations.

Questions readers ask

Is Ego Is the Enemy worth reading?

Yes, if you are ambitious and early in your career, or sitting on a recent success or failure and unsure what to do with it. The advice to talk less, stay a student and make yourself useful is sound, and the stories make it easy to remember. The case rests on anecdotes chosen to fit the point rather than on evidence, and the chapters repeat themselves by the final part.

Who should read Ego Is the Enemy?

Ambitious people early in their careers, and anyone who has recently had a big success or a painful failure and is not sure how to carry it.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 5 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play