Overview
Daniel Goleman, a psychologist and science journalist, published this book in 1995 and brought the term emotional intelligence to a wide audience. The concept itself came from the researchers Peter Salovey and John Mayer. Goleman argues that skills such as self-control, empathy and handling relationships affect success in life and can be taught. He uses the brain research of the time. Critics say he overstated how much these skills predict.
In brief
Beyond IQ
Goleman argues that emotional skills explain much of the success in life and work that IQ alone does not. Later research suggests he overstated how large that share is.
Self-awareness
Goleman puts first the ability to notice what you are feeling while you feel it. A person who can name their anger has a chance to decide what to do with it.
Empathy
Most feeling is shown through tone of voice and expression, not words. Goleman says people who read these signals well tend to do better in friendships, marriage and work.
Learning emotional skills
Goleman argues that these skills can be improved with teaching and practice. He describes school programmes that train children to manage anger, wait for rewards and settle disputes.
Who should read this
People who are good at their studies or their job but keep losing their temper, freezing under pressure or clashing with others. Also worth reading for parents and teachers.
Who might skip it
Skip if you want the rigorous academic version — the construct of emotional intelligence has been contested, and some psychologists argue it's less a distinct trait than a repackaging of conscientiousness and agreeableness. Also skip if you find the business-book chapters (EI at work) formulaic, which they often are.
What Goleman means by emotional intelligence
Goleman's claim is that academic ability explains much less of how a life turns out than we assume. He suggests that IQ accounts for roughly a fifth of the factors behind success at most, which leaves the larger share to other things. Among those other things he puts a set of emotional skills.
He builds on the work of the psychologists Peter Salovey and John Mayer and groups the skills into five areas. They are knowing what you feel, managing those feelings, motivating yourself, recognising feelings in other people, and handling relationships. Most of us know someone who topped every exam and still struggles at work because they cannot take criticism.
Goleman treats these skills as learnable. Temperament gives each of us a starting point, but habits of emotion are shaped by experience, above all in childhood, and can be reshaped later with effort.
When emotion takes over the brain
Strong emotions can act before the thinking part of the brain has had a chance to weigh in. Goleman calls this an emotional hijacking. Drawing on the research of the neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux, he describes how signals from the eyes and ears reach the amygdala, a small structure involved in fear and anger, by a short route that is faster than the route through the reasoning areas of the brain.
This made sense for our ancestors. If something in the grass might be a snake, jumping first and checking afterwards kept you alive. The same wiring causes trouble now. A message in the family WhatsApp group sounds like an insult, and you have replied sharply before reading it twice.
The first surge is quick. In the seconds after it the thinking brain catches up, and it can either calm the reaction or feed it with more angry thoughts.
Noticing and managing your feelings
Self-awareness is the skill on which the others depend. Goleman means something simple by it, which is noticing a feeling while you are having it. A person who can say to himself that he is getting angry has already gained some distance from the anger.
On managing emotions, the book corrects a popular belief. Letting your anger out by shouting does not drain it. The research he cites, including work by Dolf Zillmann, suggests that venting keeps the body aroused and makes the anger last longer. What helps is to cool down physically, by walking away for a while, and to question the thought that started the anger. The driver who cut in front of you may be rushing to a hospital.
Goleman is realistic that none of this removes bad feelings. The aim is for them to be in proportion to what happened, and to fade in reasonable time.
Waiting for the second marshmallow
The ability to delay a reward is, for Goleman, the root of self-control. He describes Walter Mischel's experiment at Stanford, in which four-year-olds were offered one marshmallow now or two if they could wait for the researcher to come back. Some ate the sweet at once. Others covered their eyes or sang to themselves until the time was up.
Followed up years later as teenagers, the children who had waited were reported to be more confident, better at handling frustration and stronger in their studies.
He links this to optimism. Using Martin Seligman's research, he argues that people who explain a failure as something they can change keep trying, while those who blame a permanent flaw in themselves give up. A student who fails a test and thinks he did not prepare properly will study differently next time. One who decides he is stupid will stop.
Reading other people
Empathy grows out of self-awareness. The better you are at reading your own feelings, the better you read those of others. Goleman points out that people rarely put emotions into words. They show them in tone of voice, in the face and in posture.
He applies this to marriage through the research of John Gottman, who observed couples during disagreements. The warning signs Gottman identified include criticism that attacks the person instead of the action, and contempt shown through sarcasm. Another is stonewalling, where one partner goes silent and withdraws. Goleman advises couples to complain about the specific act and to take a break of about twenty minutes when either feels overwhelmed.
The same applies at work. Criticism given as a personal attack makes people defensive and worse at their jobs. Useful criticism is specific, offers a way to fix the problem and is delivered in person.
Teaching emotions at home and in school
Childhood is where emotional habits are laid down, and Goleman wants parents and schools to teach them on purpose. He describes parents who ignore a child's feelings or punish the child for being upset, and compares them with parents who act as emotional coaches. The coaching parent takes the feeling seriously, helps the child name it and then discusses better ways of dealing with the situation.
He also reports on school programmes that teach what he calls emotional literacy. One example is a class called Self Science, where pupils talk about real quarrels and hurt feelings and practise settling disputes. Goleman argues that such lessons reduce fighting and improve attention in class.
The book closes with a warning that children are growing up more troubled. His remedy is to treat emotional skills as seriously as reading and arithmetic.
Try this week
- Three times a day this week, stop and name what you are feeling in one word.
- When you feel anger rising, leave the room or the chat for twenty minutes before you reply.
- The next time you criticise someone, describe the specific action and suggest a fix instead of commenting on their character.
- After a setback, write down one cause that is within your control and one thing you will do differently.
Our honest take
The headline claim that emotional intelligence matters more than IQ is stronger than the evidence allows, and many researchers find that IQ is still one of the best predictors of job performance. The concept is loose and overlaps heavily with ordinary personality traits. Later studies of the marshmallow test found much weaker effects once family background was taken into account.
If you liked this
Working with Emotional Intelligence, Goleman's own follow-up. For the skeptical view, read Adam Grant's essays on why EI is over-rated.
Questions readers ask
Is Emotional Intelligence worth reading?
Worth reading for the chapters on anger, empathy, marriage and children, which explain the research plainly and give advice you can use. Treat the headline claim that these skills matter more than IQ with doubt, because the evidence does not support it.
Who should read Emotional Intelligence?
People who are good at their studies or their job but keep losing their temper, freezing under pressure or clashing with others. Also worth reading for parents and teachers.
How long does this summary take to read?
About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.
Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.
Get the app
Share your thoughts
Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.