Business

Good to Great

This summary is also available in Urdu. یہ خلاصہ اردو میں پڑھیں ←

Overview

Jim Collins and a research team spent five years studying eleven American companies whose share returns moved from average to well above the market and stayed there for fifteen years. They compared each with a similar company that did not improve and looked for what differed. The findings are given as a set of concepts. Several of the eleven later struggled, and Circuit City went bankrupt, which has led critics to question the method.

In brief

Level 5 leadership

The leaders of the eleven companies were mostly quiet and modest, yet stubborn about results. Collins says they gave credit to others when things went well and took the blame when they did not.

First who, then what

Collins's image is a bus. The successful companies first got the right people on board and the wrong ones off, and only then decided where to drive.

The Hedgehog Concept

Each company found one simple idea where three things met: what it could be best in the world at, what drove its profits, and what its people cared about most.

The flywheel

No single action made the difference. Collins compares the change to pushing a heavy wheel, where each push adds a little speed until the wheel's own weight keeps it turning.

Who should read this

Managers, founders and people running family businesses that are doing fine but have stopped improving. Business students will also pick up terms that managers still use in meetings.

Who might skip it

Skip if you're sceptical of business books built on retrofitted narratives. Collins's method — pick winners, look for common traits — is the classic survivorship-bias trap, and several of his winners have since been big losers. Phil Rosenzweig's The Halo Effect is worth reading as a direct counter.

How the study was done

Collins and a team of researchers spent about five years asking whether a good company can become a great one, and how. They searched decades of stock market records for companies that had performed at or below the market average for fifteen years, then reached a turning point, and beat the market by at least three times over the next fifteen. Eleven companies passed. Each was paired with a comparison company from the same industry that had similar chances at the same time and did not improve. Walgreens, a chain of pharmacies, was set beside its rival Eckerd. The grocery chain Kroger was set beside A&P.

The findings are what the eleven shared and the comparisons lacked. Collins reports several things the team did not expect. The turnarounds were mostly led by insiders, not by famous executives hired from outside. There was no launch event or named program. New technology helped the companies once they were moving but did not start the change.

Level 5 leaders

Every good-to-great company had, at the time of its change, a leader of a type Collins calls Level 5. These leaders combined personal humility with a very strong will. They were ambitious for the company and not for themselves. Collins says he did not go looking for a leadership finding and resisted it at first, but the data kept pointing there.

His best-known example is Darwin Smith of Kimberly-Clark, a quiet company lawyer who became chief executive. Smith decided the traditional paper business had a mediocre future, sold the mills, and put the money into consumer products such as Kleenex and Huggies.

Collins describes a habit he calls the window and the mirror. When things go well, these leaders look out of the window and credit other people or good luck. When things go badly, they look in the mirror and take responsibility. Leaders of the comparison companies often did the reverse.

People before strategy

Collins expected great companies to begin with a new direction. He found they began with people. His image is a bus. The leaders first got the right people on the bus and the wrong people off, and only then worked out where to drive it. His reasoning is that if people joined because of where the bus is going, you have a problem when the direction must change. If they joined because of who else is on board, changing direction is much easier.

He offers some working rules. When in doubt about a candidate, do not hire, and keep looking. When you know a change of person is needed, act instead of delaying for months. Put your best people on your biggest opportunities, not on your biggest problems. The owner of a tuition centre could apply this by finding two teachers who care about students before deciding which new courses to offer, since the teachers will shape which courses succeed.

Facing facts without losing faith

The good-to-great companies looked directly at unpleasant facts about their situation. Collins names the attitude after Admiral Jim Stockdale, who was held as a prisoner of war in Vietnam for years. Stockdale told Collins that the prisoners who did not survive were the optimists. They kept telling themselves they would be home by a certain holiday, and each time the date passed they lost heart. Stockdale never doubted he would get out in the end, but he did not pretend about how bad the present was. Collins calls holding both attitudes together the Stockdale Paradox.

In business terms, Kroger and A&P both had evidence that the old style of grocery shop was dying. Kroger accepted it and rebuilt its stores. A&P looked for ways to defend the old model. Collins advises leaders to ask questions before offering answers, and to examine failures without hunting for someone to blame, so that staff bring bad news early.

The Hedgehog Concept

The name comes from an old saying, used by the essayist Isaiah Berlin, that the fox knows many things and the hedgehog knows one big thing. Collins found the great companies behaved like hedgehogs. Each had a simple understanding of itself, built from three questions drawn as overlapping circles. The first asks what you care about most. The second asks what you can be the best in the world at, and equally what you cannot. The third asks what drives your economic engine, which he narrows to a single measure of profit per something.

Walgreens is his example. It decided it could be the best at convenient neighbourhood pharmacies, and it switched its main measure from profit per store to profit per customer visit. That justified opening many shops close together on busy corners. Collins stresses that a Hedgehog Concept is an honest understanding of what you can be best at, which is different from a wish or a target.

Discipline and the flywheel

With the right people and a clear concept, Collins says, a company needs discipline more than rules. He argues that bureaucracy exists to make up for undisciplined people. A large part of discipline is refusing things, and he recommends a stop-doing list alongside the usual list of tasks.

His closing image is a huge, heavy flywheel. The first push moves it a few centimeters. You keep pushing in the same direction, and after many turns its own weight starts to carry it. Nobody can say which push caused the speed. To outsiders the good-to-great companies appeared to break through suddenly, while the people inside described years of steady work with no single defining moment. The comparison companies were caught in what he calls the doom loop. They tried a new program or a big acquisition, got disappointing results, and changed course again before any momentum could build.

Try this week

  1. Write a stop-doing list with two activities that eat your time but fall outside your main strength, and end one of them this week.
  2. Draw the three circles for yourself or your business and write an honest answer in each, including one thing you cannot be the best at.
  3. In your next meeting, ask three questions before you give your own opinion, and invite the bad news first.
  4. The next time something goes well, name the person who deserves the credit, and the next time something goes wrong, write down your own part in it first.
  5. Pick one number that best shows the health of your work, such as profit per customer, and record it every week.

Our honest take

The book came out in 2001 and several of its eleven companies later did badly. Circuit City went bankrupt, Fannie Mae was taken over by the US government during the 2008 financial crisis, and Wells Fargo was caught opening accounts that customers had not asked for. Critics argue that the method picks winners with hindsight and then finds virtues in them, so the findings may describe what success looks like more than what causes it. Greatness is also measured only by share price, and one of the eleven is a tobacco company.

"Good is the enemy of great. And that is one of the key reasons why we have so little that becomes great."

— Jim Collins, Good to Great

If you liked this

Built to Last, Collins's earlier book, covers similar ground. The Halo Effect by Rosenzweig is the essential critique of the whole genre.

Questions readers ask

Is Good to Great worth reading?

Yes for managers and anyone running a business, with the warning that several of the eleven companies later failed and the method has been questioned. Read it for the ideas and the vocabulary that managers still use, not as proof that those ideas cause success.

Who should read Good to Great?

Managers, founders and people running family businesses that are doing fine but have stopped improving. Business students will also pick up terms that managers still use in meetings.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, in English and Urdu, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play