Self-Help

The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck

This summary is also available in Urdu. یہ خلاصہ اردو میں پڑھیں ←

Overview

Mark Manson, a blogger, writes against the habit of constant positive thinking. His argument is that we have a limited amount of care to give, so we should choose carefully what we spend it on and let the rest go. He says pain and failure are part of any life worth having. The language is blunt and full of swearing, and the advice is closer to old philosophy than the title suggests.

In brief

Choosing your struggles

Manson says everyone wants the reward, so the more useful thing to ask is what pain you are willing to put up with. Happiness, in his account, comes from solving problems you have chosen.

You are not special

Manson argues that being told we are all exceptional leaves people feeling entitled and anxious. Accepting that most of life is ordinary removes the pressure to prove otherwise.

Good and bad values

Manson says good values are based on reality, helpful to others and within your control, such as honesty. Poor values, such as popularity, depend on things you cannot control.

Doubting yourself

Being sure you are right stops you from learning. Manson suggests holding beliefs loosely and aiming to be a little less wrong over time, since nobody arrives at the final truth.

Who should read this

People who are tired of being told to think positive and who worry about too many things at once, such as other people's opinions and what everyone is posting online. It suits readers in their twenties most.

Who might skip it

Skip if you find gratuitous profanity off-putting — the word is in the title for a reason, and the book doubles down throughout. Skip also if you want careful argument; Manson is a persuasive essayist but a casual philosopher, and his citations of Nietzsche and Camus can feel undergraduate.

Caring about fewer things

Despite its title, the book does not recommend indifference. Manson's claim is that attention and concern are limited, so you have to choose where to spend them. A person who cares about every comment and every small insult has nothing left for what matters.

He starts with a trap he calls the feedback loop. You feel anxious, then you feel anxious about being anxious, then you get angry at yourself for it. Social media makes this worse. Everyone else appears to be happy and successful, so feeling bad starts to look like a personal failure.

His answer borrows from the philosopher Alan Watts, who described a backwards law. Chasing a positive feeling reminds you that you lack it, which is itself a negative experience. Accepting a negative feeling calmly is a kind of positive experience. Someone who accepts that he is nervous before a presentation usually speaks better than someone fighting to feel confident.

Choosing your problems

Manson argues that a life without problems does not exist. Solve one and a new one appears. Getting a job solves the problem of having no income and creates the problems of a long commute and a difficult boss. Happiness, in his view, comes from solving problems you are glad to have.

Everybody wants the same comfortable things, so asking what you want to enjoy tells you little. He says to ask what discomfort you are willing to put up with. He tells his own story here. For years he dreamed of being a rock musician. He loved imagining himself on stage, but he did not love the daily practice or carrying equipment to rehearsals. He wanted the result without the process, so it never happened.

A student who says she wants to be a doctor can test herself the same way. The white coat comes with years of long study hours and night duty, and what counts is whether she can accept those.

Being ordinary is fine

Manson criticises the message that every person is exceptional and destined for greatness. He thinks it produces entitlement. Some people come to believe they deserve good things without earning them. Others believe their problems are so unusual that normal rules do not apply to them. In both cases the person sees himself as a special case.

Most of us are average at most things. The internet hides this by showing us the extremes all day: the class topper and the millionaire at twenty-five. Against that background an ordinary life looks like failure.

Accepting that you are ordinary removes pressure. You can then enjoy plain things, such as a good friendship or helping someone, without feeling you have fallen short. It also makes work easier, because people who accept that they are not already great are the ones willing to practise.

Better and worse values

How you measure yourself decides how you feel, more than what you achieve. Manson tells the story of two musicians. Dave Mustaine was thrown out of the band Metallica just before it became famous. He went on to found Megadeth, which sold millions of records, yet by his own account he still felt like a failure because he measured himself against Metallica. Pete Best was removed from the Beatles shortly before their success. After some difficult years he built a quiet family life and said he was happier than he would have been in the band.

From this Manson separates good values from bad ones. Good values are based on reality, help other people and lie within your control. Honesty and standing up for yourself are examples. Bad values depend on things outside your control or do harm, such as being liked by everybody or being rich for its own sake. A student who measures himself by the effort he puts in has a standard he can meet every day. One who measures himself by rank depends on how forty other people perform.

Responsibility is different from fault

Manson separates two ideas that people mix up. Fault is about who caused a situation. Responsibility is about who has to deal with it now. His example is a baby left on your doorstep. It is not your fault that the baby is there, but what happens next is your decision, and even doing nothing is a choice.

This matters because blaming others, even when the blame is fair, leaves you waiting for them to fix your life. Someone whose parents could not pay for a good school is not at fault for a weak start. He is still the only person who can do something about his English or his skills today.

Manson also asks readers to hold their beliefs loosely. We are wrong about many things, and certainty stops us from learning. He notes that people avoid whatever threatens their picture of themselves. A man who sees himself as a talented writer may never send out his work, because a rejection would damage that picture.

Acting first, and remembering that time is short

On failure, Manson passes on advice from a maths teacher of his. If you are stuck on a problem, do not sit and think about it, just start working on it. He calls this the do something principle. We assume motivation leads to action, but it also runs the other way. A small action produces a bit of motivation, which leads to more action. Someone avoiding a long assignment can promise to write only the heading and the first paragraph, and often finds he keeps going.

He also argues that commitment brings a kind of freedom. Rejecting options, by staying with one career or one place, lets you go deep instead of tasting everything. Saying no is part of having values at all.

The book closes with death. Drawing on Ernest Becker's book The Denial of Death, Manson says that remembering life will end is what puts small worries in proportion. He describes how the sudden death of a friend when he was nineteen changed his own direction.

Try this week

  1. Write down the three things you worried about most this week and cross out any that will not matter in a year.
  2. For one goal you have, list the daily discomforts it requires and decide honestly whether you accept them.
  3. Replace one measure you cannot control, such as your class rank, with one you can, such as hours studied.
  4. Pick a task you have been avoiding and do only the first ten minutes of it today.
  5. Say no to one request or invitation this week that does not fit what you care about.

Our honest take

Little here is new, since the main ideas come from Stoic and Buddhist thought and from modern therapy, and Manson offers little research to support them. The rough language and jokes, which helped the book sell, will put off many readers and make some serious points sound flippant. Many stories come from his own life as a young, travelling American, which may feel distant. The later chapters wander, and the advice to care less is easier for someone without family duties or money pressure.

"Who you are is defined by what you're willing to struggle for."

— Mark Manson, The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck

If you liked this

Everything is F*cked, Manson's follow-up, is less good. For the serious version of the argument, read the Dalai Lama's The Art of Happiness.

Questions readers ask

Is The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck worth reading?

Yes, if you can take the swearing and want old Stoic ideas in plain, modern language; readers in their twenties get the most from it. If you already know those ideas, or carry heavy family and money duties, much of the advice will feel thin.

Who should read The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck?

People who are tired of being told to think positive and who worry about too many things at once, such as other people's opinions and what everyone is posting online. It suits readers in their twenties most.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, in English and Urdu, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play